Modern
Means of Communication and Interreligious Dialogue
Prepared by the Rev Dr Joshva
Raja with the suggestions from Fr Dr Michael Traber presented to Federation of Asian Bishop's Conference in 2005 at Bali, Indonesia
1. Modern Means of Communication
Communication is a process of
sharing, informing, interacting, exchanging, sending and receiving messages,
meanings and means among the participants. The modern means of communication in
this paper includes those technological means such as newspapers radio,
television and internet, their genre (digital, analogue, cable and Direct To Home
-DTH), their content (films, news, Soaps) and formats (entertainment,
educational). These means have established their own cultures of communication and
created their own space for communicating, entertaining, marketing and
manipulating. The space among the mass audience is constructed and used for
different purposes. The same means are also used by many with alternative
approaches, perspectives and goals. In this paper I am going highlight the ways
in which modern means of communication, their cultures and people’s use can be
recognised by those who try to promote a culture of interfaith dialogue among
the different religious communities.
Recent events have shown that the
modern means of communication can make a tremendous influence on the mind and behaviour
of the people in a particular context at a particular time. Media have enhanced
and at times even produced new priests, preachers and leaders for the public
such as televangelists, Net preachers, electronic churches and Radio priests (S Hoover[1]).
Religion has also been brought into every genre of entertainment industry
(sports Cricket and prayer). To some extent I agree with Prof Gregor Goethals[2]
that Television has replaced the traditional roles of the teachers and the
churches in promoting values and faith to the audience. The modern means of
communication package religion like any other goods and sell in the market of
audience. Thus a popular religion has emerged with proofs, demonstrations of
miracles and emotional claims with the help of the mass media. This has made an
impact on the way people use these modern means of communication. To some
extent the new technology has segmented the audience into different cultural
and sub cultural groups according to their interest. The technique of persuasion
is used by the new tele-religious groups with the help of technology and skills
they try to persuade the fact that theirs is the true and ultimate way of
religion.
Professor Michael Traber[3]
my colleague and friend during an interaction told me that, the modern media of
communication, which includes the mass media and the computer/telephone based
media like the Internet, are, generally, not interested in interfaith dialogue.
The reason for this is simple. He argues that a vast majority of media users does
not comprehend, and care for, the theological intricacies that are part of this
type of dialogue. But the media do care about interfaith actions. After all,
inter-faith relations and activities are part of the daily life and reality of
the people of most of Asia. They do not call
them interfaith activities, but, simply, good neighborliness (incidentally, a
Biblical term of great importance). For him as neighborliness, regardless of
the neighbor's religion, is so much part of daily life - in India and I presume
elsewhere in Asia - media reports on interfaith relations and actions reflect
people's lives with their neighbors, colleagues and friends, with whom they
interact as a matter of course, regardless of creed and religious convictions. I
will also discuss this later and highlight the importance of acting or working
together in interfaith dialogue. The major issues in inter-religious dialogue
and media are use of media to promote dialogue; representation of religious
communities in the media; Culture and values of the media and access and space
for religious communities. I am analyzing the existing models of Interfaith
Communication before I highlight the different ways of using and engaging in
the media to promote inter-religious dialogue among different religious
communities.
3. Inter-religious Dialogue
Dialogue means communication
between two persons or communities or nations. It is a two-way communication[11]. In
the multi-religious context dialogue refers “to all positive and constructive
inter-religious relations with individuals and communities of other faiths
which are directed at mutual understanding and enrichment in obedience to truth
and respect for freedom” (n.9 =G 933 Fitzgerald 2004:1)[12]. Inter-religious
dialogue refers to “discussions for mutual understanding held among differing
religious bodies” (McKim 1996: 147)[13]. For
the Vatican Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, inter-religious
dialogue presupposes that each side wishes to know the other and wishes to
increase and deepened the knowledge of the other[14]. Interreligious
dialogue can either be an ongoing process or means to an action or an end in
itself. I mean interreligious dialogue as a process in which people at
grassroots level are engaged in interacting, discussing and exchanging views,
beliefs and ideas in their daily activities as they come across people of other
faith in their jobs or business or otherwise. Interreligious dialogue is often
used as a means towards development of people or liberation or towards a common
action that would benefit all regardless of religions. It can also be a means
for establishing a civil society or realising their rights and so on.
Interreligious dialogue refers to establishing contact, communication,
relationship and understanding between those communities that do not have such
elements or do not want to have such elements of dialogue with other
communities. In this way dialogue can be a process, means and end in itself. Among
the other denominational circles interfaith dialogue is often used. The
understanding of Interfaith dialogue has evolved through the discussions of
International Missionary Council and then in the WCC’s assemblies. Interfaith
dialogue was understood “as an encounter between people who live by different faith
traditions” (Ariarajah 1991:4)[15]. The
best way to define the dialogue comes from the prayer of Upanisad where the
Guru and Shisya (disciple) were supposed to say together this –
Saha Navavathu Saha Navbunakthu[16] May He (God) protect us both together
May
He nourish us both together
Sahaviryam Karavavahai May we both work together
with great energy
Thejasvi Navadhithamasthu May
our study be vigorous and effective
Ma vidvishavahai May we not hate each other
The above prayer shows that those
who are engaged in dialogue and in search for God have to work together, learn
together, engage in a positive relationship with each other and thus God’s
protection and blessings will be on both. Thus both (Guru and disciple) become
learners in the dialogue. The inter-religious dialogue involves God’s full
presence, our active involvement in working, learning and establishing
relationship with each other.
Inter-religious dialogue means to
establish a contact and communication between two or more religious persons,
communities or nations. The purpose of the inter-religious dialogue can be
stated in different ways that lead to inter-religious action. One of such
purposes is to increase understanding between different religious communities and
thus to remove ignorance about each other. The second purpose can be to
establish a good relationship between different religious communities and thus
support the coexistence of religious communities. The third purpose is to
engage with each other in search for ultimate truth. Thus those who engage in
each other’s faith and religious journey may find nourishing and learning
together. The fourth purpose can be to face the struggles of life together and
address special issues such as globalisation, HIV/AIDs and drug addiction
together as communities of faith
There are many other purposes
with which inter-religious or interfaith dialogue can be organised. It is
increasingly becoming essential for the religious communities to come together
and hold dialogue in order to avoid unnecessary misunderstanding, collision and
conflicts. Dialogue does not require giving up, hiding or seeking to validate
one’s own religious conviction rather it emphasises the need for being rooted
in one’s own faith convictions and also to find a way to live alongside with
other faith traditions (Ariarajah 1991:4). In my paper concepts and practice of
inter-religious and interfaith dialogue may overlap at times.
Inter-religious Dialogue includes
four main activities –Inter-religious Communication, Interfaith Action, Inter-religious
(spiritual) Experience and Interfaith Search. I recognise that Fr Michael
Amaldoss and also Michael Fitzgerald have already distinguished four different
levels of dialogue: the dialogue of life; the dialogue of intellectual exchange;
the dialogue of spiritual experience and the dialogue of common action[17]. I
also realise similar distinctions are made by Mr Peter Kemp in his article on Towards a Dialogue of Learning and
Criticism, in which he expands Fr Amaldoss’ into detailed distinctions[18]. My
distinctions are based on the three major Margas of Srimad Bagavad Gita and my own addition of Jeeva Marga after reading
Fr Amaldoss’ dialogue for life. These margas will be used when we analyse the
dialogue and modern means of communication. In the Dominus Iesus (Declaration on the Unicity and Salvific Universality of
Jesus Christ and the Church, August
6, 2000) inter-religious dialogue is seen as part of the churches’
evangelizing mission[19].
Equality in dialogue refers to the equal personal dignity of the parties in
dialogue, not to doctrinal content. In this way inter-religious dialogue can be
seen as an important responsibility of the church in doing mission and
ministry.
5. Four Margas
First Inter-religious
communication involves a process of establishing contact, discussion,
interaction and relationship between different religious communities. This
effort is basically to establish some common ground on which people from
different religions can live, communicate, act and interact together. It aims
at knowing the basics of the other and trying to understand the other. This
might remove ignorance that one may have about the other. This communication
should lead to a coexistence of different religious communities. Discussions
can be based on addressing issues related to a life together. This can also be
possible both at leadership and grassroots level. I classify such dialogic
attempt as Jeeva Marga (the Path of Life)[20].
In this path three stages of communication
are essential to follow that are contact (thodarbu
– in Tamil – Rev Thomas Thangaraj uses this term), relationship (uravu), understanding (arivu). Through
this dialogue we need to establish these three stages of communication. It is
also reflected in the present Pope’s statement to the Indian Bishops on 26th June 2003[21],
Inter-religious dialogue will not only increase mutual understanding and
respect for one another but will also help to develop society in harmony with
the rights and dignity for all. This clearly shows that at leadership level the
churches wanted to encourage the people to engage in dialogue and thus coexist
with other religious communities in harmony and peace with justice and human
dignity. The best example is Duyog Ramadan [Fitzgerald 2004:2] in Southern Philippines. This programme helps Christians
accompany (Duyog) Muslims during the month of Ramadan. Through Radio, sermons
and talks the Christians are made aware of how Muslims observe Ramadan.
Secondly Interfaith Action
involves a process of acting together in the social processes such as
eliminating the poverty, exploitation and corruption in our society. This
effort is to work together towards the betterment of human beings and human
society in general. It can be identified as Karma Marga (the Path of Action)[22].
In Bangalore
we have dialogue groups that exist with different purposes. One of them is in
Whitefield Asrham of Guru Prabhakar where he introduces the concept of action
together – which he calls Annaprasadha (sharing
of food). This programme is held once in two weeks in villages where people
come together before a religious shrine, bring different food items and cook
the food together and share it with all. Regardless of religions people are
expected to come and join in this meal sharing. This is not a charity
(Annadhana) though all share this food. Even in my campaign against conversion
bill introduced by Tamil Nadu Government many Muslims and Hindus joined us in
the public procession. Inter-religious dialogue should lead us towards
communicative action. The dialogic communication should lead us towards
community building, human dignity and support of local cultures. World
Conference on Religion and Peace (WCRP) focus mainly on dialogue for action.
WCRP has contributed towards the setting up of an inter-religious council in Sarajevo and also a similar one Sierra Leone which is engaged in
the rehabilitation of child soldiers [Fitzgerald 2004:3].
For Michael Traber if, however, inter-faith cooperation
in social actions are genuine and public, many mass media, including news and
feature services, would carry such reports, sometimes even with pictures. I can
see fours reasons for this:
1)
Most
media, but particularly the print and electronic media, have a commitment to
peace and harmony in their countries in many democratic countries of Asia. This is particularly true for India where most of the media have
a 'secular agenda', which means that religions are to serve the nation and its
people as a whole, without advancing particularistic religious interests.
2)
Some
mass media have a deep concern for social justice. They feel that it is a shame
that people still live in poverty and ignorance. They also have a sense of
solidarity with those who are most marginalized in society, like, in India,
the Dalits, the so called Tribals, and women oppressed by a patriarchal system.
They, therefore, appreciate joint social actions by representatives of
different religions.
3)
Related
to this is the fact that the media in general are said to set the 'public
agenda'. Which means they raise and emphasize topics and concerns, which they
think are important for the public at large and for government in particular.
They are, in general, pleased if they see that
representatives of different religions are part of their 'public agenda'
and, in fact, can be used for their agenda setting processes.
4)
The
fourth reason for the media's interest in religion is perhaps the most
important one: The mass media in general acknowledge that religion is important
for their readers, listeners and viewers. This fact has been brought out by
many communication researchers (Steward Hoover, Knud Lundby, Jolian Mitchell,
Paul Soukup et al.). The reason for this is simple: Most people, and
particularly Asian people, are religious, or, to put it more accurately, have a
religious sense. Producers and editors sometimes manipulate this for their own
reasons, as, for example, in stories about seers and saints, miracles and
mysteries. But that should not deter us from the basic principle that most
media recognize the religious needs of the people and are trying to meet these
needs in some respects.
Traber considers Mother Teresa as an example of
all these points just mentioned. She is a media phenomenon still ultimately
unexplained. And I know of no scholarly study that could shed light on why
blessed Mother Teresa was such a favoured of the media in India and beyond. The Hindu,
one of the truly outstanding newspapers of India, hardly carries any news
about Christianity and the church. But when Mother Teresa had a fever, it was
front page news. The only explanation I have is this: What Mother Teresa did,
rather than what she said, touched the hearts of the majority of Indians in a
way no other religious news did. She did something very simple, namely loving
the poorest of the poor, which was immediately understood by people of whatever
religion and genuinely appreciated and admired.
Thirdly Inter-religious Experience
involves engaging in each other’s search for meanings of life and of God and
thus making a search for ultimate reality and take all together towards God. It
also involves in participating in each other’s religious activities to test and
find whether some of them are meaningful, relevant, nourishing and useful to
all. This effort is basically to learn more about each other’s spirituality and
faith. It can be identified as Bhakti
Marga (the Path of Devotion)[23]. Here
the spirituality forms the basis of dialogue between people. Particularly those
elements that are used for spiritual experience can also be shared among
different communities[24]. When
I tune or compose Bhajans in Sanskrit, in Telugu and in Tamil somewhat the UTC
students and others like them and so sing them often. Interestingly we found
some of these Bhajans transcend the religious barriers, in particular the
music. Some of the Bhajans or tunes are immediately borrowed by other religious
communities [Ariarajah[25]
1999]. Symbol, signs, rituals, lyrics, music or acoustic instruments enable
people to transcend their religious barriers. People recognise the similarities
in spiritual experiences in different religions. Kabir is a poet who brought different
traditions together in his Urudu poems. G U Pope a great Western missionary and
Tamil Scholar who read thiruvasagam and commented if you are not shedding your
tears while reading Tiruvasagam (A Tamil Saiva siddhanda religious poetical
text) you will not shed your tears for any other book. The spirituality has
brought people together. The dialogue can focus on sharing people’s different
spiritual experiences and their bhakti traditions.
Fourthly Interfaith Search refers
to a participation in the search for the ultimate reality through intellectual
discussions and exercises. There should be a space for dialogue that leads to
an intellectual exchange between different religious communities. Such an
exchange would continue to nourish each other’s faith and enable them to listen
together with people of science, people without any faith and people with
different ideologies. This can be identified as Jnana and Dhyana Marga (the Path of Knowledge and Meditation)[26].
I added Dhyana intentionally because no search begin from outside in Indian
thinking and so begin discovering self. Only when we begin to discover our self
we begin to learn little bit about the Self and thus our relationship with the
other ‘self’s. In all the above stated margas neither change of religion nor
any mission from one religion to other can happen but people learn together,
listen to each other and thus grow in their respective faith. This is a process
of sharing, learning and listening together. I was engaged in a number of
dialogue programmes. One of them was a controversial dialogue between Christian
leaders and Rashtriya Sweyam Sevaksangh (RSS) in Bangalore 2002. The leader Mr
Sudhersan was leading the RSS and a few Bishops were leading Christians. During
the first half the dialogue was a failure because both blaming each other and
defending their own positions. The dialogue was successful to some extent that
both critically engaged with the other and slowly was trying to understand the
other. It led them to a conclusion that we need to engage in a continuous
dialogue with each other.
It is also a search together the relevant
meanings of religion, of community and of life. It is a search for the ultimate
reality or truth. In this dialogue one can engage in the other’s search for
meanings and thereby learn together. This dialogue often remains at
intellectual and representatives level. In the guidelines to Nostra Aetate No 4, the Vatican
Commission demanded the dialogue members to go beyond friendly talks and
identify those competent people to meet and to study together the many problems
deriving from the fundamental convictions of Judaism and Christianity[27].
The understanding of the interfaith/inter-religious
Dialogue has been developed through the centuries which are often classified as
inclusive, exclusive and pluralistic schools of thought[28]. In these dialogical interactions how does communication
play a major role or can play an important role is our concern. Thus I would
like to focus on the models that are used for inter-religious dialogue and
group them into a few selected models. This would certainly help us to There
are many ways in which the interfaith or inter religious dialogue was developed
at different levels. But now I am grouping some of them under different models
of interfaith communication. I have borrowed the name of the models from a few
scholars which I mentioned with the models themselves.
6. Modern Means of Communication and Inter-religious Dialogue
I agree with Dr Samartha (1991:
59) that Dialogue is between people and so it much a matter of relationships,
discussions and communication. There can be no dialogue between ‘faiths’ or
‘religions’ or ‘ideologies’[29]. Dialogue
is communication between the two persons or communities. From an Islamic
perspective Dialogue is a dimension of human consciousness (not sceptical), a
category of the ethical sense (not cynical). It is the altruistic arm of Islam
and Christianity, their reach beyond themselves. Dialogue in short is the only
kind of inter-human relationship worthy of human beings[30]. Different
types and means of communication can enhance the inter-religious dialogue. This
is already recognised by S J Samartha in his writings. He argues that not only
the symbols of religious life and practice, particularly music, art, devotion,
meditation and the controlled use of silence but also the verbal communication
are essential part of the dialogue. (Samartha, 1981:7)[31].
It is essential that we use the media for enhancing the process of dialogue. What
place different means of communication can play in the interfaith dialogue is
my question. One has to realise the fact that lay people are yet to be
convinced of the need for the dialogue. When we talk about the role of
different means of communication we need to identify multiple approaches. This
will enable us to engage both in the communication and also in the interfaith
dialogue with an open heart and with wider possibilities.
I have grouped the approaches
into a few ways: Dialogue with the Media, Dialogue through the Media, Dialogue
about the media, Dialogue in the Media, and Dialogue and the Media. But our dialogue is with the people. There
are a number of attempts by many of the religious groups and institutions to
initiate, sustain and nourish inter-religious dialogue among different
religious communities. This is happening at the intellectual, leadership,
representative and elite level. Organised inter-religious dialogue are familiar
to many of us at this level. But unorganised dialogue is happening at the
grassroots level (interpersonal, group, community and mass level) everyday. In
many cases it is an every day reality where inter-religious discussions become
unavoidable. But because of the recent hate campaign and ignorance the dialogue
at the grassroots is not happening. There are not many organised dialogic
groups or dialogic action groups. The purpose of the grassroots dialogue is to
enable people to come in contact with other religious communities, to
communicate, to understand and to establish relationship with each other.
Our interaction with the media should
enable us to nourish the dialogue at grassroots and find news ways of
establishing the contact, communication, relationship and thus understanding
which I call inter-religious dialogue. But it is not only discussions but
communication and relationship involves action and also joining spiritual and
intellectual journeys together along with other religious communities. Any dialogue
that is not bringing together people, enabling them to establish understanding
and thus remove ignorance about each other and not making them to act together
does not sustain itself for a longer period. The main aim for me in the
inter-religious dialogue is to promote the discussions at the grassroots level.
Nevertheless it is important to maintain the dialogue at the intellectual and
leadership level too without which dialogue at grassroots becomes impossible. In
this case means of communication can mediate between different dialogic groups
and enable them to be networked among themselves.
Dialogue with media-people – It means to hold dialogue with the
media professionals, personal and media practitioners. The media play a major
role in reflecting and shaping public opinion, they have great potential to
facilitate dialogue between religious communities. This potential is not
automatically realised as the media operate under financial constraints, strong
competition, commercial marketing considerations, a growing demand for visual
material and a public demand for sensational and exotic news. Media
professionals need to become more aware of the vital role that the media play
in informing the public, their potential to foster dialogue, mutual respect, peace
and justice between different religious communities [Abdelnasser[32] 2004:1].
Some of them need an orientation to different religions with a practical
exposure and with certain ethical discussions about the representation of the
other in the media. Many of our religious leaders and academicians need to
realise the limitations of the mass media industries and practices. We need to
look at their positive roles in the society as well. It is a dialogue between
media personal and religious leaders and scholars. It often leads us in
discovering each other and understanding the other. In this sense we start with
Jnana Marga – that is an
intellectual discussion on representation, values and role of the media in
establishing harmony and peace. This
intellectual discussion needs to establish regular correspondence, access, space
for each other and thus create an atmosphere of understanding between them. This
may lead to a culture of participation, constructive critique of each other,
learning and working together towards peace and harmony of the society. Thus a
dialogue is essential with the media personal.
In the pastoral instruction
document Aetatis Novae (24) it is clearly mentioned that there should be a
pastoral outreach to and dialogue with, media professionals, with particular
attention to their faith development and spiritual growth [Eilers 1996: 135].
It continues saying, ‘in seeking to enter into dialogue with the modern world,
the Church necessarily desires honest and respectful dialogue with those
responsible for the communications media… Such dialogue, therefore, requires
that the Church be actively concerned with the secular media, and especially
with the shaping of media policy. …The dialogue incolves support for media
artists…” [Eilers 1996:128]. It is clear that the church has recognised the
media as powerful means for dialogue.
First it is essential that the
churches hold dialogue with the media professionals first and then through them
we extent our dialogue with other religious communities. Through our dialogue
we may enable the media practitioners as mediating and reconciling agencies of
dialogue. In the Criteria for Ecumenical and Inter-religious cooperation, it is
clearly demanded of Christian communicators to cooperate with members of other
religions working in the field of communications for the preservation,
promotion and coordination of the expression of a religious viewpoint in the
media [Eilers 1996:157]. At times such reporting or representations are done
with intentions where dialogue with the media should become a critical and
prophetic engagement with them. When I held the meeting for the media on the
Perception of Islam in the Media there was a good response from the industry.
They went on reporting about our programme. But many of those media
representatives tended to justify or defend their positions. There was a
dialogue between Muslim leaders and the media representatives in such a way
that many of them began to realise each other’s limitations as well as the need
for a change. This brought a slow change in the way religions were reported in
the main stream media in Bangalore.
We hold dialogue with the media personal in order to widen the dialogue to
other people. In this dialogue other religious friends (both from the majority
and minority communities) must be involved in order to bring about a better
understanding to the public through their reporting.
Dialogue through the Media – It refers to having a dialogue with
the audience through the media. It aims at using any media as technological
means for promoting dialogue at grassroots. The purpose is to promote
inter-religious dialogue among the audience using different means of
communication. We are not talking about the content here rather the
technological and form of the media. It means to make the media as platform for
inter-religious dialogue. For example Internet is known for its interactive
technology. So our attempt is to make the technology available for different
religious communities to interact among themselves. The interactive programmes
(such as phone calls) in radio, television can be specially produced in order
to encourage the audience to engage in different types of interfaith dialogue
among them. The basic purpose is here to act – to use the media to bring people
together and talk which otherwise may or may not be possible. Then the use of
the media should lead to Jeeva Marga – which
means to enable the people to come together through the media and thus try to
establish a contact, communication, relationship and thus understanding between
them. It is where the use of the media for inter-religious dialogue becomes an
essential one. In what ways the media can be used in an effective way in order
to bring about dialogue among the public.
Religious media can play a major role
in enhancing dialogue between different communities. It is essential that we
create a multi-religious public space. Our media often aim at meeting the needs
of our denomination members though some of them reach to other audiences. The
best way of promoting a multi-religious public space is to widen the scope of
our media to meet the needs of different religious communities. We can also try
to form multi-religious voluntary groups based on a variety of cultural and
social interests like music, arts and drama and so on [Amaladoss 2004:6]. We
need to begin to create occasions for symbolic celebrations of different
religions and other social and national festivals. In the Communio et
Progressio (114) the Pontifical commission clearly mentions about the need for
the churches to look for the ways of multiplying and strengthening the bonds of
union between the members. For this reason communication and dialogue among
Catholics are indispensable [Eilers 1996:99]. It continues saying, the church
does not speak and listen to her own members along; her dialogue is with the
whole world (Communio et Progressio 122). This shows the dialogue between
members should be extended to a dialogue with others. This means our
understanding of community should be an exclusive and narrow rather it should
enable us to create, provide and access to an inter-religious space where we
can listen and interact with others.
In the document of Criteria for
Ecumenical and Inter-religious Cooperation (16,17,19), Cooperation among
different religions can be realised in every aspect of social communication.
This is already in itself a witnessing before the world. Inter-religious
cooperation will take into account the specific context of production and
planning on the local, regional, national or international level. Joint project
have as their aim to allow Christians and members of other religions to give a
common witness to God. A reciprocal trust and understanding among Catholic,
other Christians, and members of other religions, based on mutual respect, and
with a view to doing things together in communications. Christians are called
to give fair and objective information on other religions of humanity [Eilers
1996:159]. Many are exploring the possibilities of using different means of
communication in order to encourage dialogue at different levels.
New technologies embody a huge
potential to facilitate inter-religious dialogue. The Internet in particular
provides lots of opportunities to easily communicate with members of other
faiths. It breaks the borders and boundaries of nations, though there are
limitations. The new media contribute to increased, diversified and decentalized
information flows [Abdelnasser 2004:1]. The accessibility, availability and
affordability are still serious issues that have to be addressed if we are
thinking of using these technologies. Though the best form of communication is
face to face communication we may consider some of these technologies and their
characteristics in enhancing the inter-religious dialogue. The internet
provides us a high speed and exchange of information that can enhance a good
relationship among the users. It is also an interactive culture that has
evolved in the net where the gap between sender and receiver has been reduced
to active participants role. The net provides convergent and hypertext
technology through which all the analogue means of communication are brought
into one machine and the search is done according to what we need rather than
according what is made available.
The net has also evolved with new
questions of self such as (Virtual Self), the relationship between God and I
(the second most searched subject in the net is God among the billion users!). It
is also found out that 64% of wired Americans have used the Internet for
spiritual or religious purposes [Hoover[33] 2004:iv].
These characteristics of the new net culture may help us to enhance the
dialogue between different religious communities where some may want to engage
in the dialogue without releasing their identity and so on. My paper on ‘Internet, Mission and Ecumenism’ is published in a
number of journals including Mission
Today (2004,August) and placed by
the EMS Stuttgart as documentation on the net both in English and Deutsch.
Dialogue about the Media – This is an effort to engage with the
people in talking about the media. It focuses on the audiences’ use of the
means of communication. The audience will engage in discussions about different
religious reports that are presented in the media. Often people use media for
different purposes. At time different means of communication may provide them
right knowledge and at times may not do so. This is a grassroots dialogue where
people come together and use media as source of discussions. It leads to action
– that means to act together to establish further relationship (friendship);
understanding and thus community’s relationship will be strengthened. People
will start critically reading the media, write to them and avoid those media
which are promoting communal tension and violence. It also enables people to
work together towards helping and developing each other and bring about
reconciliation where it is needed. This method leads people to carry out Karma Marga – acting together to bring
about communal harmony and peace. A critical and discriminatory engagement
about the content and technique of the media and its practice will help the
audience to use them constructively. It is clearly mentioned in the document Communio et Progressio, “Reviews of
Radio and television broadcast, of films and illustrated magazines can be of
help in cultural and religious education. They will also help those who wish to
make a wise choice of what the media have to offer” [Eilers 1996:99]. In
Aetatis Novae the churches are asked to include media education in the pastoral
plan for social communication with a special emphasis on the relationship of
media and values [Eilers 1996:24]. The pontifical council encourages further
efforts at cooperation with the members of other religions to promote religious
and moral values in the field of social communication. Most of our dialogue
today depends on the content of the media. It would be easy for the groups or
representatives to talk about the media and their content and thus initiate an
inter-religious dialogue.
People can start analysing how
the religions, particular communities or poor people or marginalised
communities are represented in the media. Through such deconstructive learning
the people not only engage in the inter-religious dialogue but also become
constructive and critical users of the media. There is a need to conscientize
the religious communities in order to challenge and change the incorrect
attitudes, prejudices and biases towards others and remove the ignorance of the
masses [Amaladoss[34]
2004:5]. We have to create news experiences of community through dialogue and
common action for justice. Change of attitudes takes place not only through
preaching, not through abstract argument, but by actually encountering the
others in multi-religious groups. This is where dialogue has to go to the
grassroots in order to nourish understanding and relationship between different
religious communities.
It is essential that
multi-religious communities are formed not only to engage with the media in a critical
manner but also to act together to promote human dignity, justice, peace and
equality in the non-religious sphere or politics and society [Amaladoss 2004:6].
During the riots the arms of the government should be neutral. Such movements
must be multi-religious and so media should give appropriate commentary that
enables people to awaken and conscientize rather than provoking a mad
collective frenzy [Amaladoss]. Coalitions are happening and some newspapers,
magazines and tabloids are playing a major constructive and critical role in
presenting the stories about clashes. Not only the media but also the audience
should learn to be critical users and readers of the media.
Media critique can be a starting
point of such dialogue – particularly in relation with the discussions about
the representation of religious communities. Hess [1999] writes about this in
detail how media literacy can become a support for development of a responsible
imagination in religious community, enable us to recognise the multiple ways of
knowing and constructing meanings and help us in deconstructing some of our
liturgies and so on[35]. We
have similar programmes such as media awareness programmes which are
increasingly becoming popular among the school children and also becoming part
of the school education system. The media-talk and God-talk can nourish each
other while they can correct the other too from their respective perspectives. The
critique of the media should go along with appreciation about their excellent
contribution to the society at large.
At the same time there is a need
to democratise the media, promoting freedom of expression and information at
various levels of society, enhancing a free flow of information and ideas to
all, transfer of communication technology for development of communities. The
inter-religious dialogue can lead to discuss these issues while focussing on
the religious related issues. There should be an openness to listen to the
critique of the media towards religious leaders that they avoid media. Many of
the religious institutions do not have a constructive and continued
relationship with the media and their personal. This can generate a lot of
discussions at all level about why media construct realities in this way when
it comes to religion? This is not only a starting point but can become a
sustainable process of dialogue. Particularly talking about the media in
relation to religion can initiate the dialogue and also encourage even the
young generation to interact with others.
Dialogue in the Media – It means to present the inter-religious dialogue
programmes to the media for reporting. It aims at developing the content of the
media in order to promote the inter-religious dialogue among the public. In the
content the religious leaders have to come together and try to promote among
themselves an understanding through a demonstrated dialogue. Through other
genres (Drama, film and so on) the dialogue can be promoted. In this program
basically we need to develop strategies where spiritual exercises that are
similar and converging in meanings can be done together. Thus an interfaith
liturgy can be organised or a presentation of an interfaith liturgy can be
presented in the media. Thus this leads to both a discussion among
intellectuals (Jnana Marga) and also
sharing of spiritual exercises through common liturgy or some common
performance or at least clipping together some common demonstrations of
different religious communities which is Bhakti
Marga. We need to develop programmes of dialogue for the media and invite
the media for reporting our dialogue programmes.
We need to make sure that even in
our media we present a good image of inter-religious dialogue so that people
might be convinced. The content should merely not reflect the wealth, education
or political power. The right to communicate is the right of all. It calls for
special efforts not only to give those who are poor and less powerful access to
the information which they need for their individual and social development but
to ensure that they are able to play an effective, responsible role in deciding
media content (Aetatis Novae 15 – Eilers 1996:131). It calls us to promote
inter-religious dialogue as an essential aspect of public communication. The
content of the inter-religious dialogue should be presented in the public media
as basic information that is needed for all the communities. Without such
efforts the content often becomes too negative in the media’s presentation of
religious communities in general and no space for the inter-religious messages
in particular. If this is neglected then it is taking away certain people’s
right to inform about themselves and thus clarify certain suspicion or
misinformation provided about certain religious communities. It is essential
for all the religious communities not only to provide information about them
but also to provide a dialogic approach towards others.
Traber points out the fact that the media do
not create stories or reports about anything, least of all about interfaith
activities. They basically report on what comes to their attention. If there
are no interfaith actions, or if they are phony, the media will have nothing to
report on. Therefore, the fundamental question is: Are the churches and their
leaders really engaged in inter-faith relations and actions, and if so, how
public is their engagement. It would of course be wrong and ultimately
counter-productive, if church leaders engaged in ecumenical actions for the
sake of publicity. The media would be quick to discover such intentions, and
would dismiss them as public relations.
.
There is yet another aspect of the mass media
which is important for our discussion about interfaith relationships. It is the
fact that media focus on 'events'. An event is something that stands out in the
sequence of time, either in the calendar of religious feasts or in the
civic-secular calendar. In addition, events of interest to the media are public
happenings that are expected to capture the attention of media users. Here is
an example, taken from the Diwali issue (p. 12) of Jesuit Parivar,
published in Mumbai:
On the birthday of Our Lord Jesus
Christ, that is, on Christmas Day 2003, we had a large gathering of
inter-religious leaders and prominent personalities, including members of the
Lions Club. The Mayor of Nashik presided over this function…At this function,
one of the speakers applauded the activities of this parish: [its] activities
have spilt over the church walls and invite and embrace the inter-religious and
cultural groups in Maharashtra. Nashik, our
pilgrimage city, has many shrines of various religions. Holy Cross Church is not only a shrine but also a
vyaspitha (a platform for inter-religious and cultural sharing), and is
increasingly seen as such.
The Holy Cross parish of Nashik created a
public event, meaningfully on Christmas day, a day closely associated with
Christianity. The idea was simple: to share the joy of Christmas with members
of other religions and the public at
large. The presence of the Mayor and the Lions Club would indicate that it was
probably more of a civic event, but with deep religious meaning.
Another example is the story of the
Sri Lankan Bishops making a group visit to 'top Buddhist monks', which appeared
in Asia Focus (a UCAN News and Feature Service) on 21 May, 2004. All eleven Catholic
bishops of Sri Lanka paid
their respect to the heads of the largest Buddhist monasteries in Kandy. The bishops could
have decided that this was a private visit, which, incidentally, nobody would
have believed. Instead, they planned it as a public event, during which
"the two most serious political issues facing the country" were
discussed, namely "the struggle for Tamil autonomy and te hung parliament
following the recent general election" (Asia
Focus. 21 May 04, p.6). There was no interfaith dialogue during this
encounter between Buddhist and Christian leaders, but a common concern for the
problems of the nation. This was an 'ideal' media story, showing religious
leaders in joint action - albeit only 'verbal' symbolic action.
Another example of symbolic action is the
churches involvement in a Hindu festival which is considered of special
importance for education. A SAR news story (1.11.04) reports: "The various
churches in Kerala initiated hundreds of children into the world of letters …
as part of Vijayadashmi, a popular Hindu
festival… considered the most auspicious for starting learning." At a
special ceremony some 70 children were initiated into the world of letters by
making them write the first letter of the alphabet of the Malayalam language,
in keeping with an age-old custom practiced on Vijayadashmi.
Please, note that this celebration is held
jointly by different Christian churches on a feast day of Hindus. This is an
example that genuine inter-religious dialogue is not only concerned with other
religions but also with ecumenical relations with other Christian churches. All
too often those most eager to engage in inter-religious dialogue think that
this is some kind of substitute for cooperation with other churches.
Ultimately, interfaith cooperation and inter-church dialogue and cooperation
have the same root, namely, the unity and cooperation of all humankind.
Dialogue and the Media – This is where we need to be open to listen
to what the media expect from inter-religious groups. In what ways their trend
and framework can enable us to become an interesting dialogic group. It means
to shape our own dialogical initiatives and change according to the needs of
the media. It may be risk to compromise with our ideals but for the sake of
promoting interreligious dialogue we may consider some of the offer of the
media that would disseminate and spread an interest in the dialogue at
grassroots. For example the media may ask for a story or drama rather than for
a discussion to promote dialogue. This is where we may have to do accordingly
to promote the concept and practice of dialogue at various levels. A New
interactive culture is emerging in the new technological media. This may enable
and help us to provide space for those who wish to interact and engage with
them in their interactive search for meanings of life and of God. Our search
would be how the dialogue at grassroots can be nourished by the new emerging
culture of the media. In what ways we can interact and incorporate the culture
of the new media which can enable the representatives, leaders, intellectuals
and people at the grassroots to develop a culture of dialogue. The search for
meanings of life often begins from oneself. Thus within every, person, culture
and religion there is a search for meanings of life and of God. How far one
engage in other’s search for meanings is an essential question in our dialogic
adventure. It is know as Dhyana Marga whereby one not only meditates on one’s own
self but also try to engage with the other in his or her meditation and search
for God. The dialogue begins by being a self-retrospective in our approach and
engaging in other cultural and religious search for meanings of life and of
God. People use media in search for meanings of Life and of God in which we are
called to engage in their search and listen to them. While listening they do
provide us a space for our own meanings to be presented to them among an array
of meanings that are available to them.
6. Examples of Dialogue using the Modern Means of Communication
a. Television
i.
Listening
Project
The main aim
of this project is to enable people from different religious communities to
listen to each other and thus cultivate a better understanding among them. “We
believe that the need for Muslims and Christians to listen to, and talk with
one another is urgent in our time. This opportunity for personal interaction
can effectively open doors to understanding Islam, and to exploring how
Christians and Muslims are dealing with the realities of modern life in
particular countries of the world as well as here at home”. Building relationships, like keeping a productive garden,
is a lot of work. It requires attention and hands-on involvement, but it is
satisfying, and fun! The work brings nourishment and happiness to yourself and
many others. From their experience they realized that it is a good thing to
study about Islam, and to read about the dynamics and complexity of
Christian-Muslim relations in various countries of the world. However, deeper
personal understanding more often comes out of meeting and talking face-to-face
with Muslims and Christians who live and work together. The
Interfaith Listening Project hopes to help you plant and sustain relationships
of understanding and mutual discovery with your Muslim neighbors, and to learn
more about Islam and our world. This project will bring visiting
Christian-Muslim teams to some 25-30 selected locations in the United States
from September 23-October 7, 2004. This program has been very successful one at
grassroots. They have used Internet to broadcast this and made the programme
popular among different communities in US. This sets a good example for others
to follow. You can download this in your computer and see the webvideo. www.pcusa.org/listeningproject/
ii.
Broadcast
Model
National
Council of Churches in US have initiated with an Interfaith Broadcasting Commission through which the faith
community provides television programming assistance to ABC, NBC and CBS
each year. The Interfaith Broadcasting Commission exists to secure that
attention from the electronic media for religion and religious values which
their status in the minds and hearts of the American people merits. The IBC is
made up of the NCC and three other partners:
- U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, Washington DC
- Southern Baptist Convention Broadcast Group, Ft.Worth, TX
- Jewish Theological Seminary of America, New York City
To fulfil this purpose the IBC
seeks:
1.To heighten within the
electronic media industries and the general public an awareness of and
appreciation for Judeo-Christian principles and their importance in American
life.
2.To demonstrate through
programming a variety of ways in which faith is expressed in the lives of
individuals.
3.To inspire individuals via the electronic
media to explore ways in which faith can enrich their lives.
4.To influence in positive ways
the quality and values of all programming.
The members from different
religious communities produce their inter-religious programmes from their own
perspective and broadcast by rotation. One of their programs titled ‘Christian
and Jewish Dialogue Today’ will be broadcast in December. This program will try to popularize those
stories of dialogue between Abrahamic religious communities. Much has been
done, and is being done today, to bring these two Abrahamic religions to new
levels of respect and understanding. The program will celebrate the gains made
and openly explore the progress still to be made and the hopes of all to
achieve it. This program is scheduled to air on CBS stations and
affiliates, December
19, 2004 through January 9, 2005. VHS copies of the 30-minute program
will be available for purchase. www.interfaithbroadcasting.com
Faith and Values Media (formerly
National interfaith Cable Coalition) draws on a variety of faith traditions to
bring you a range of viewing choices. Music, worship, magazine shows, talk
shows, movies of the week, documentaries and specials - Faith & Values
Media offers outstanding selections in every category. Faith & Values Media is the nation's
largest coalition of Jewish and Christian faith groups dedicated to media
production, distribution and promotion. Its member association is made up of
denominations, organizations and individuals, who encompass most of the
recognized Jewish and Christian faith groups in the United States. Together, these
faith groups have more than 200,000 congregations with 120 million congregants.
The programming services of Faith & Values Media are available on the
Hallmark Channel and on www.faithandvalues.com.or
www.wofav.tv . Faith & Values Media is a
service of the National Interfaith Cable Coalition, Inc., established in 1987. Join
us on the Hallmark Channel and experience television that's truly worth
watching. One of the documentary films that this group will show on December 19th
is Reluctant Saint: Francis of Assisi. This film will show how the saint
transcends the image familiar to us. Such a kind of programs will popularize interfaith
stories and activities.
Horizon
Interfaith is a non-profit multi-faith organisation,
with representatives from many different religions and faith groups across the
Greater Toronto Area, who produce and air TV programs about their beliefs and
interfaith viewpoints. Our overall purpose is to encourage and co-ordinate the
use of communication media, especially those electronic in nature, by religious
groups in Metro Toronto and beyond. Our aim is to share with viewers the
beliefs and traditions of our diverse religious community, to emphasise values
in life as addressed by religious beliefs, and promote harmony and
understanding of our multi-cultural, multi-faith and multi-racial community in
our interfaith programming. In the new millennium we
are very excited to be expanding our presence to the Internet with the
development of a Website. This will enable us to offer our viewers more
information about Horizon, our member faith groups and airing programs, as well as
to provide a preview of upcoming programs to our viewers. www.horizoninterfaith.net/ (For Radio one can visit a number of websites
for details – www.newafricaradio.com/
)
The Council
of Churches in the Netherlands
has prepared a short text of Eid al Fitr (the festival marking of the end of
Ramadan) greetings to Muslims through the press and other media. www.en.ch/highlights/news.shtml?2001/11
c. Internet
i. Interfaith
Interaction
A website I constructed with the help of my engineer Mr
Saju to provide a platform for interfaith dialogue groups to share their
experiences. We started with 27 members and now we have world major
institutions and other scholars from all over the world around 170 members. For
the past three years we have been sharing interesting, exciting and emotional
exchanges between different religious groups, organisations and institutions
all over the world. You may look at my website www.interfaithinteraction.org and also we have a yahoo
discussion group which is also called interfaith interaction yahoo e-groups
through which we share our experiences stories and greetings.
ii. Interfaith Pals
The main
aim is to use ICT to
develop knowledge and understanding of the beliefs and traditions of two major
religions in British society. This activity was used with children in key stage
2, years 5 and 6.The main objectives
are: To address any misunderstandings about religious differences by
using e-mail to generate an interfaith dialogue;To consider the conventions,
strengths and limitations of using e-mail as a means of communication; To
collect and transfer files as e-mail attachments; To learn to be sensitive to
the needs of the e-mail reader through careful use of 'specialist' vocabulary.
This activity relates not only to development of understanding of different
benefits and transactions but also to the key stage 2 ICT programme of study,
particularly: sharing and exchanging information (3a); being sensitive to
the needs of an audience (3b); reviewing what has been done to develop ideas
(4a).
Activity This
activity was part of a religious education project to establish a network of
'e-pals' between two schools in the same city: one with a largely Muslim intake
and the other with a Roman Catholic tradition. In planning the project,
teachers from both schools met to establish aims and objectives. They agreed
guidelines for the e-mail exchange and considered how they might intervene
during the series of exchanges to ensure positive outcomes. In order to show
how e-mail communication can generate a real-time dialogue, the teachers set up
an agreed timetable for sending and receiving messages. All the teachers and
children were actively involved in creating and sending the e-mails. This
provided opportunities for teachers to demonstrate features of the e-mail
programme, such as the 'reply button' and the 'address book'.
The initial exchanges between the
schools focused on personal introductions. The children shared information
about their interests and hobbies. This was designed to break the ice and
develop relationships between the children. Later, they shared information
about their religious backgrounds and beliefs, especially about the Christmas
and Eid festivals that were happening at the time of the project. As the
dialogue developed, the children's exchanges focused on the themes discussed in
religious education lessons. During these exchanges the children were
encouraged to say if they disagreed with something. They were encouraged not to
dismiss ideas and beliefs but to explore different points of view in a positive
way. By this stage of the project it was noticeable that the exchanges included
both serious questioning about religious beliefs and questions about shared
interests, hobbies and families.
Throughout these exchanges, teachers
in each school intervened to pose and develop the thinking of all the children.
Towards the end of the project the children were taught how to attach files to
e-mails. They were encouraged to e-mail pictures and video greetings to one
another. The project culminated in the children from both schools meeting up in
a city park during the summer term. The children each used downloaded and
printed images to help identify their e-mail partners.
Commentary The project worked well: the
children used e-mail to exchange and share ideas about their religious
traditions and beliefs. The immediacy of the dialogue meant that any
misconceptions could be explained as soon as they arose. The children found the
direct e-mail interaction with their peers motivating: the contact enriched the
teaching of more traditional paper-based work. As the project progressed, the
children began to appreciate the similarities and differences in their respective
religious beliefs. They explored and discussed common misunderstandings. They
also noticed that they shared many interests, hobbies and experiences. The
teachers in both schools felt that these exchanges went some way towards
developing the children's understanding of different religious cultures and of
the need to reduce any prejudice and/or suspicion they may feel regarding other
traditions.The information and communications technology schemes of work can be
found at www.standards.dfes.gov.uk/schemes. The online national curriculum can
be found at www.nc.uk.net .
iii. The
Interfaith Internet Community Action Network
The Interfaith Internet
Community Action Network (ICAN) comprises over 10,000 e-mail activists who
receive regular updates on issues of concern to The Interfaith Alliance. We are
The Interfaith Alliance and The Interfaith Alliance Foundation. Founded in 1994
by an interfaith group of religious leaders, we work to promote interfaith
cooperation around shared religious values to strengthen the public’s
commitment to the American values of civic participation, freedom of religion,
diversity, and civility in public discourse and to encourage the active
involvement of people of faith in the nation’s political life. We are local
religious leaders and activists, some with years of political experience, some
just starting out. We work in our communities, in state capitals, in Washington, DC
and wherever else our voice is needed.
Our 150,000 members across the nation represent diverse religious and spiritual traditions – Jews, Christians,Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs – 70 faith traditions in all, as well as many Agnostics and Atheists. In Washington, DC, our national office works on Capitol Hill and with the White House, in coalition with denominational bodies and other activist organizations to make sure our unique message is communicated when and where it matters most. Our 47 local Alliances are active in their communities on local issues, carrying The Interfaith Alliance message to decision-makers, the media, and the public at large. www.interfaithalliance.org/
Our 150,000 members across the nation represent diverse religious and spiritual traditions – Jews, Christians,Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs – 70 faith traditions in all, as well as many Agnostics and Atheists. In Washington, DC, our national office works on Capitol Hill and with the White House, in coalition with denominational bodies and other activist organizations to make sure our unique message is communicated when and where it matters most. Our 47 local Alliances are active in their communities on local issues, carrying The Interfaith Alliance message to decision-makers, the media, and the public at large. www.interfaithalliance.org/
iv. Net, Dialogue and Development
Using
the internet, we need to explore the possible ways of serving the many
sidelined communities: refugees, prisoners, oppressed communities, HIV/AIDs
infected farmers, fishermen, labourers and people below poverty line (BPL). The
area of Internet and Development is another paper which I have already submitted
at major conferences in India
and elsewhere. I wish to point to a few models that I proposed in that paper -
Web-cafe model[36], Web
radio model[37] and
Multicasting model[38].
These models have been studied by the local governments in India to explore the possibilities
of using Information Communication Technology for development. People at the
margins should be given a chance to communicate their own problems, among
themselves, and to the public. We have
successful stories of such communication in Gujarat
where SEWA has done this with a video camera. Information technology can
provide information to these people at the margins about useful Government
programmes. At the same time they can express themselves to the outside world
and bring their problems, and other issues, to the notice of the government.
Some NGOs are already involved in the net for such development[39].
Making a video clip or an audio file in these systems is very easy, and then
placing or sending it from one place to another place is also made easy through
the convergence technology.
Conclusion - Integrated Approach
to Means of Communication and Dialogue
Inter-religious dialogues are
happening all over the world, thanks to religious leaders, scholars, media
personal and others for their initiatives and examples that in many parts of
the world religions do co-exist. In this paper I highlighted a few ways of
enhancing the dialogue by involving the media in the process. Four Margas are
only guidelines to make an attempt to further interreligious dialogue between
different communities of faith. One of the major concern that the dialogue
remains at intellectual and leadership levels. People in people’s everyday
dialogue (that I call the dialogue at the grassroots) tend to avoid any
religious matters due to fear of arguments, wasting time and conflicts of
interests. We need to explore engaging with media to encourage, nourish and
support such dialogue at grassroots so that people will have contacts,
communication, relationship and understanding. Our churches have enormous
potential to engage in this process of establishing groups of dialogue at
grassroots. One should realise that there is lack of trust, suspicion, fear of
holding dialogue with others, religious indifference, scepticism, cynicism
about inter-religious dialogue, a strong belief in self-sufficiency, cultural
remoteness, and aggressiveness in promoting or defending one’s own faith and a
feel of insecurity are a few reactions from the people at grassroots [Crollius[40]
2000:3-4].
I do not want to generalise that
all at grassroots have such feelings. But inter-religious dialogue has not
penetrated the churches – I mean our members so that they can establish small
groups in most of our parishes (in the schools or in our other institutions)
that would nourish inter-religious dialogue. The integrated approach for me is
to engage with the media in diverse ways in such a way that the local opinion
leaders, interpersonal communication, groups, communities are influenced and
persuaded by our communication. We need to give systematic training to
representatives of different religious communities how to develop these small
groups for inter-religious dialogue for life, action and experience at
grassroots. We can also give them, also for our priests and theological
students - a training to use various means of communication to promote
inter-religious dialogue at every level of the society. We need to interact
with the media personal and others sensitising them to an inclusive and prudent
use of language, visuals and audio material about others (particularly
minorities) in their content. We can also explore simple alternative media to
mediate between the main stream media and people and thus our own magazines,
websites can also be used for promoting the inter-religious dialogue. Rather
than thinking about the use of media for promoting dialogue, in this paper I
have highlighted a number of ways to engage with the media in a constructive
manner that would educate us and others to recognise different ways of
participating in inter-religious dialogue.
[1] Hoover, Stewart M. Mass
Media Religion: the Social Sources of the Electronic Church. (Communication and
Human Values) Newbury
Park: Sage Publications,
1998.
[2]
Goethals, Gregor T. Electronic Golden Calf: Images Religion and the Making of
Meaning. Cambridge:
Cowley Publications, 1990
[3]
Michael Traber, Notes on Media and Interfaith Dialogue, 2004, Bangalore: UTC. I am privileged to include
his suggestions into my paper.
[4]
John Joshva Raja Facing the Reality of
Communication: Culture, Church and Communication. 2001 Delhi:ISPCK.
[5]
Avery Dulles, Christ Among the Religions, The
National Catholic Weekly, February, 4, 2002, Vol 186, No 3,p 1-12).
[6] R
Panikkar, The Intrareligious Dialogue.
Paulist Press New York,
1978.
[7]
Francis, D 1983, ‘Christianity, Culture and Communication’, The South India Churchman (now CSI Life), July, 10-11.
[8]
Maulana Wahiduddin Khan, Progress in
Inter-Religious Dialogue. http://www.alrisala.org/Articles/papers/progress.htm
[9] M Fethullah Gulen, ‘The Necessity of
Interfaith Dialogue: A Muslim Perspective’, Fountain,
Vol. 3, Issue 31, 2000, pp.4-9.
[10] D
G Moses, Evangelism – ‘The Mission of the Church to those outside her life’, The South India
Churchman. 1954, June 4-5.
[11]
The Pontinfical Council for Inter-religious Dialogue, ‘Methodology of PCID’, www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/interelg/documents/rc_pc_interel
[13]
Donald K.McKim, Westminster
Dictionary of Theological Terms, Philedelphia: WJK, 1996.
[14] Guidelines and Suggestions for Implementing
the Conciliar Declaration, Nostra Aetate, No.4, Vatican Commission for
Religious Relations with the Jews, December 1, 1974. http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/relations-jews-docs/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_19741201_nostra-aetate_en.html
[15] S
Wesley Ariarajah ‘Interfaith Dialogue’,
in The Dictionary of the Ecumenical
Movement, N Lossky, J M Bonino, J. Pobee, T Stransky g Wainwright and P
Webb eds, Wm B Eerdmans Publishing Co. Grand Rapids, 1991.
[16] Svetasvatara Upanisad, Translated by
Swami Tyagisananda, Madras:
Sri Ramakrishna Math, 1987.
[17]
Michael Amaldoss, "Freedom in the Spirit and Interreligious
Dialogue", Studies in Interreligious Dialogue 8 (1998) 5-18.
Michael Fitzgerald, Developing Dialogue,
2004. (Dialogue of Life; Dialogue of Action; Dialogue of theological exchange;
Dialogue of religious experience). Mr Sean Dwan suggests Discursive dialogue
(debate), human dialogue (Buber-meeting as human beings), Secular dialogue
(joint action), spiritual dialogue – from the Inter-religious dialogue, www.Dwaninterreligiousdialogue.org
[18] Peter Kemp, Towards A Dialogue of Learning
and Criticism, A Paper presented at the International Conference on the
Dialogue of Civilizations, United Nations University, 3rd August 2001, Kyoto. His distinctions
are: 1. The Dialogue in ordinary life and practice 2. The dialogue in
intellectual exchange of interpretations of life and practice 3.The dialogue in
mutual effort for discovering common experiences and complementary despite
differences 4.The dialogue between human beings sharing the same historical
experiences of values and beliefs.
[19]
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith – Dominus Iesus: Declaration on the Unicity and Salvific Universality of
Jesus Christ and the Church, August
6, 2000. www.bc.ed/research/cjl/meta-elements/texts/documents/catholic/cdf-dominusiesus
[20]
Advesta sarvabhutanam maitrah karuna eva ca friendly
and compassionate to all
nirmamo nirahamkarah sama
dhukha sukha ksami and without any
touch of hatred devoid of
possessiveness and arrogance
santustah satatam yogi
yatatma dradha niscayah ever
content and contemplative alike happiness and
misery, self controlled and firm in
conviction
mayy arpita mano buddhir yo
mad bhaktah sa me priyah dedicated to
me with all his heart and all his soul
is the real devotee to me and is
dear to me.
(Sri Gita 12:12)
[21]
Extra ecclesium nulla salus, ‘Inter-religious Dialogue is Part of Evangelising
mission, Pope says.. It Implies Profound Respect for Culture He tells Indian
Bishops’, Vatican City,
June 26, 2003, http://www.tcrnews2.com/genjp2000.html
[22] Sri Gita 5: 7 – one who is
established in selfless and detached action, who is pure, whose mind and senses
are under control and whose self is identified with the self of all – he is
never bound though he be engaged in work. 5:12 By abandoning the fruits of action (service to
others) a man of restrained mind attains to abiding peace.
[23] Sarva Bhuta stham atmanam sarva
bhutani cathmani – The person of spiritual insight, established in
same sightedness sees the Self as
residing in all beings
iksathe
yoga yuktatama sarvatra samadaranah – and all beings as resting in the
Self. Sri Gita 6:29
[24]
Giuseppe Scattolin, Spirituality in
inter-religious Dialogue:Challenge and Promise. In Encounter, 274, April 2001.
[25] S
Wesley Ariarajah, ‘Dialogue and Spirituality: Can We Pray together?’ Chapter 3
of Not Without My Neighbor: Issues in
Interfaith Relations. Geneva:World
Council of Churches, 1999, pp.26-58.
[26] Sri Gita 7:23-26 Those who worship
the Devas go to Devas, but my devotees attain to me. People with little
knowledge look upon me as a mere human individual, having come manifestation
from an unmanifested state. I know all beings – past present and future. But
none knows me.
[27]
Guidelines on Nostra Aetate 1974…
[28] I
have analysed these there in details in a recent article on Doing Theology in a Pluralistic Context,
presented to Ecumenical Christian Centre, Bangalore.
[29] S
J Samartha, “Inter-religious Relationships in the Secular
State’ in Interfaith Dialogue and World Community edited by Mr Ch Sreenivasa
Rao, 1991, Madras:CLS.
[30] Isma’il Ragi A. Al Faruqi, ‘Islam and
Christianity:Diatribe or Dialogue’, in Muslims
in Dialogue: The Evolution of a Dialogue. L Swidler, ed The Edwn Mellen
Press, Lewiston, NY, pp.1-22, 1992.
[31] S
J Samartha, Courage for Dialogue:Ecumenical
Issues in Inter-religious Relationships. Geneva:WCC, 1981.
[32]
Walid Abdelnasser, The Media and Dialogue
among Civilizations.
[33] S
M Hoover, L S Clark, L Rinie, 64% of wired Americans have used the Internet for
Spiritual or Religious purposes, Faith Online, Internet and American Life a
research, Washington:
PewInternet and American Life Project.
[34] Michael
Amaladoss, Dialogue as Conflict
Resolution: Creative Praxis www.sedos.org/english/amaladoss1.html
2004
[35]
Mary E Hess, Media Literacy as a Support
for the Development of a responsible Imagination in Religious Community,
Presented to the Media Religion and Culture Conference, Edinburgh, Scotland
July 1999.
[36]
Web-cafes are popular in urban areas of India.. Such web-cafes could be
made available in rural areas. One of the major constraints is that servers are
in city areas and so the phone lines often happen to work through STDs. But
most of the village areas are brought under local network and so such problems
in many places do not exist any more. Some computer literate person can help
people to have access to those pages that would be useful to them such as
market prices for their vegetables or for any other goods, train or bus ticket
booking, weather information for fishermen and online medical advices. For all
these people can pay a small amount for their use of computers and thereby
maintain the system.
[37]
Internet Radio stations could be made available from anywhere in the world
except in India.
By buying space in the Web and by providing the content from India, NGOs will be able to operate such
stations from rural India.
To do this one or two room broadcasting centres could be developed in villages
from where they can communicate to different parts of the world. Only by
networking and popularising such radio stations will the project be successful.
Such type of webcasting should consider entertainment, educational, informative
and development oriented programmes. This could operate like some of the
community radio centres that are already doing some narrowcasting in India.
Here the investment and operational costs are comparatively cheap. There is no
clear-cut policy by the Indian Government about webcasting. Development
oriented information can be made available to the public through such internet
radio casting.
[38]
In rural villages local Panchayat buildings have loud speakers and display
notice boards. Local village radio stations are given a licence by the
government if they are used for educational and developmental purposes. These
means could be networked with the Internet and Computer system in such a way
that the selected useful message could reach people, who in turn can also
respond to certain messages among themselves. If the people can meet together
at the computer centre, they can also communicate to other villages through the
net. I identified this as a multicasting model because ICT and other media
could be used together with a different use of ICT in different areas. This
would be cheaper than other broadcasting or narrowcasting practices. This would
be participatory event and could be modified to suit the needs of the people.
[39] MS Swaminathan Project in India
– Pondicherry -Computers are used to supply useful
information to the fisherfolk. The NGOs encourage people to participate in
using the net. People from marginalised communities think that having access to computers means a step up in their status.
Having computers in a Dalit’s village means bringing non-dalits to their place.
It also allows the Dalits to communicate to others. They provide information
about weather, pesticides, market prices, cost of seeds and fertilizer. Other
government schemes are also announced such as Women Public Welfare Schemes, low
cost insurance and health issues, Government provisions and applications online
for benefits. Mailing complaints to officials and to political leaders is also
made easy in this process.
[40] A R Crollius, 2000, ‘Inter-religious Dialogue: Can it be sincere?, inculturation, Vol XX, 1998.
No comments:
Post a Comment